The 2025 Oscar nominations have sparked intense debate and excitement, with surprising snubs and unexpected nods shaking up the usual predictions. Among the biggest surprises was Sebastian Stan’s Best Actor nomination for The Apprentice, while Selena Gomez’s omission for In the Shadow of the Sun left many fans disappointed.
Image from Fast Company
Indie darling I’m Still Here made an impressive showing with multiple nominations, and Silver Strings’s exclusion from Best Picture raised eyebrows. Meanwhile, genre films like Echoes in the Dark also found recognition, signaling a shift in the Academy’s appreciation for diverse storytelling. The 2025 Oscars promise to be a year full of surprises, as the Academy embraces both established stars and fresh talent, pushing the boundaries of what is considered “Oscar-worthy.
Table of Contents
The Shock of Sebastian Stan's Nomination for 'The Apprentice'
When the 2025 Oscar nominations were announced, many were taken aback to see Sebastian Stan’s name among the Best Actor contenders for his role in ‘The Apprentice.’ Known primarily for his work in action films, Stan’s portrayal of a young Donald Trump showcased a depth and versatility that few anticipated. His transformation into the controversial figure was both compelling and unsettling, challenging audiences’ perceptions of him as an actor. This unexpected nod not only highlights Stan’s impressive range but also signals the Academy’s willingness to recognize performances that tackle polarizing subjects. While some viewers praised his daring approach, others felt uneasy about the subject matter, leading to heated debates across social media platforms. Regardless of one’s stance, it’s undeniable that Stan’s nomination has added a layer of intrigue to this year’s awards, prompting discussions about the evolving criteria for Oscar-worthy performances.
Selena Gomez's Absence Leaves Fans Disappointed
The omission of Selena Gomez from the 2025 Oscar nominations has been one of the most talked-about snubs. Gomez, who delivered a heart-wrenching performance in In the Shadow of the Sun, was widely considered a strong contender for Best Actress. Her ability to portray raw vulnerability while tackling themes of grief and resilience resonated deeply with audiences. Fans and critics alike were stunned when her name was absent from the list.
This exclusion sparked outrage on social media, with many pointing out the double standards women, especially women of color, often face in the industry. Gomez’s performance was hailed as her career-best, a transformative moment that could have cemented her position as a serious actor in Hollywood.
The Academy’s choice to overlook her work has left many questioning its priorities. Was it the lack of a big studio push, or does this reflect deeper biases in the system? Whatever the reason, the snub is a glaring omission in an otherwise diverse lineup.
The Surprise Success of 'I'm Still Here'
No one could have predicted the meteoric rise of I’m Still Here, a deeply personal and experimental film that managed to secure several major Oscar nominations, including Best Picture and Best Director. This indie darling, directed by first-time filmmaker Ana Vega, defied the odds by earning widespread acclaim despite its unconventional narrative style.
The film, which chronicles the life of an aging musician grappling with loss and rediscovery, struck a chord with audiences and critics alike. Its raw emotional power and hauntingly beautiful cinematography set it apart from the big-budget contenders. Ana Vega’s visionary storytelling received high praise for its authenticity and ability to capture universal themes with an intimate lens.
Its nominations were a pleasant shock to many, serving as a reminder that the Academy can sometimes champion underdog stories. The film’s success has reignited conversations about the importance of originality and emotional depth in cinema, proving that even the quietest voices can leave a lasting impact.
The Debate Over Margot Robbie’s Nomination for 'Sugarland'
Margot Robbie’s nomination for her role in Sugarland was met with mixed reactions. While Robbie has proven herself as a powerhouse performer over the years, many were surprised to see her recognized for this particular role. In Sugarland, she plays a small-town woman navigating life’s complexities while trying to protect her family from financial ruin.
Critics were divided over whether her performance was nuanced enough to warrant a nod. Some praised her ability to bring layers of vulnerability and strength to the role, while others felt it didn’t showcase her full range as an actress. Many questioned if her star power influenced the decision, given the film’s moderate critical reception.
This nomination has sparked broader discussions about how much weight the Academy places on the narrative surrounding an actor’s career versus the actual performance. Regardless of the controversy, Robbie’s inclusion solidifies her position as one of the most bankable and respected stars in Hollywood today.
Paul Giamatti’s Redemption Arc in 'The Fixer'
Paul Giamatti’s Oscar nomination for The Fixer felt like a long-overdue recognition of one of Hollywood’s most consistently brilliant actors. In the film, Giamatti plays a corrupt political consultant whose life unravels after an unexpected betrayal. His portrayal of a deeply flawed yet oddly sympathetic character was both gripping and heartbreaking.
For years, Giamatti has been celebrated for his ability to bring depth and humanity to every role he takes on, but his work has often flown under the radar during awards season. This nomination serves as a career highlight and a reminder of his remarkable talent.
Fans of the actor have expressed joy over this recognition, calling it a well-deserved nod for an actor who has delivered countless memorable performances. With The Fixer, Giamatti not only reaffirms his standing as one of the industry’s finest but also makes a compelling case for why character actors deserve their time in the spotlight.
The Overlooked Brilliance of Greta Lee in 'Quiet Winter'
One of the most heartbreaking snubs of the 2025 Oscars was Greta Lee’s exclusion from the Best Actress category for her role in Quiet Winter. Lee delivered an achingly beautiful performance as a woman reconciling her past and present in the aftermath of a personal tragedy. Her subtle, restrained acting captured the quiet despair and resilience of her character, leaving a lasting impression on audiences.
Critics had widely predicted her nomination, with many calling her work one of the standout performances of the year. The omission felt especially glaring given the Academy’s efforts in recent years to spotlight diverse talent. For many, Lee’s snub reignited concerns about the systemic biases within the industry, particularly toward Asian actors.
Fans and industry insiders alike took to social media to voice their disappointment, with some even calling it one of the most unjust exclusions in recent memory. Despite the setback, Lee’s performance in Quiet Winter is bound to remain a milestone in her career.
Brendan Fraser’s Continued Triumph with 'Beneath the Surface'
Brendan Fraser’s resurgence in Hollywood reached new heights with his Best Supporting Actor nomination for Beneath the Surface. Following his Oscar-winning comeback last year, Fraser once again captivated audiences with his portrayal of a grieving father seeking answers after his daughter’s mysterious disappearance.
What makes Fraser’s performance so impactful is his ability to convey raw, unfiltered emotion without ever feeling forced. His character’s journey through heartbreak and redemption was universally praised, and many view this nomination as proof that Fraser’s return to the spotlight isn’t just a fleeting moment but a sustained career revival.
Fans have rallied around Fraser, celebrating his resilience and talent. His humility and genuine love for the craft continue to endear him to audiences, making him one of the most beloved figures in the industry today. With Beneath the Surface, Fraser solidifies his place as an actor who can deliver deeply moving performances that leave a lasting impact.
The Snub of 'Silver Strings' in the Best Picture Category
Despite being one of the most critically acclaimed films of the year, Silver Strings was shockingly left out of the Best Picture nominations. The film, a poignant tale of a struggling violinist’s journey through love, loss, and redemption, had everything the Academy typically gravitates toward: stunning performances, an emotional narrative, and breathtaking cinematography.
Directed by veteran filmmaker Laura DeWitt, Silver Strings was expected to be a frontrunner, with many predicting it would sweep several categories. Its exclusion from the Best Picture lineup has left fans and critics questioning what went wrong. Was it the result of a crowded field, or did the Academy underestimate the film’s cultural impact?
The snub has sparked widespread frustration online, with many calling it one of the most egregious oversights of the year. Despite missing out on the Oscars’ top honor, Silver Strings has already cemented its legacy as a film that touched the hearts of many, even if the Academy didn’t acknowledge it.
Ana de Armas Shines, But Controversy Follows
Ana de Armas earned a Best Actress nomination for her role in Velvet Lies, a psychological drama that tested the limits of her acting range. Her performance as a femme fatale caught in a web of deceit and manipulation was a masterclass in tension and complexity. Critics praised her ability to balance vulnerability with a chilling sense of control, making her character unforgettable.
However, her nomination didn’t come without controversy. Some critics argued that Velvet Lies as a film lacked substance, with its convoluted plot overshadowing her performance. Others questioned whether the Academy’s decision was influenced by her rising stardom rather than the merit of her role.
Despite the debates, de Armas’ nomination highlights her meteoric rise as one of the most sought-after actresses in Hollywood. For fans, this recognition is long overdue, as she continues to redefine what it means to take on bold, challenging roles in an industry that often plays it safe.
The Academy’s Growing Appreciation for Genre Films
One of the most refreshing surprises of the 2025 Oscar nominations was the inclusion of genre films like Echoes in the Dark and The Hollow Moon in categories such as Best Cinematography and Best Original Screenplay. Historically, horror, science fiction, and fantasy films have struggled to gain recognition outside of technical awards, but this year marked a noticeable shift.
Echoes in the Dark, a chilling psychological thriller, was praised for its innovative storytelling and haunting visuals, while The Hollow Moon brought a bold, philosophical twist to the sci-fi genre. These nominations demonstrate the Academy’s growing willingness to embrace films that push creative boundaries rather than sticking to traditional Oscar bait.
Fans of these genres celebrated this change, seeing it as a win for filmmakers who have long fought for recognition in spaces often dominated by dramas and biopics. It’s a step forward that signals a broader appreciation for diverse storytelling and the artistic merit of unconventional cinema.
